Brownfields  Cleanup Alternatives Summary Table                         

Home
Up
Search
Contacts
Mayor
City Officials
Council Members
Agenda/Meetings
Meeting Schedule
Park & Recreation
Historic Shelby
Newsletter
Shelby Business
Community Profile
Animal Control
Animal Ordinance
Shelby Churches
ACH Form

TABLE 1

BROWNFIELDS CLEANUP ALTERNATIVEs SUMMARY
SHELBY MIDDLE SCHOOL
SHELBY, MONTANA

Alternative

Effectiveness

IMPLEMENTATION

COST

No-Action

Short-term: Minimally effective.  Health risks will hinder re-use.

Long-term: Minimally effective.  Health risks will continue to hinder re-use

No abatement.

Institutional controls necessary, involving restricted access to areas with deteriorated ACM (RACM).

Notification required to lessees and buyers, continued management of remaining ACM and LBP. 

Ongoing O & M costs estimated at $12,000 per year. 

Alternative 2 – Abate deteriorated ACM, all LBP except wall areas;

Intact ACM flooring to remain, LBP wall areas to be encapsulated/ sealed.

Short-term: Highly effective.  Alleviates current related health risks and some long-term risks. 

Long-term: Moderately effective; Requires maintenance of remaining ACM and LBP material.  Removal of remaining ACM and/or LBP required if future renovation is undertaken.

Abates 2,000 square feet  friable ACM, and also easily removable/ replaceable LBP-containing trim, doors, windows, etc.

LBP floor coating in locker rooms to be removed.

Institutional controls necessary, involving notification to lessees and buyers, continued management of remaining ACM and LBP.

Removal estimated at $78,200.  Cost does not include replacement of removed items.

Alternative 3 – Abate all ACM and LBP

Highly effective.  Alleviates current and long-term risks.

All ACM and LBP would be removed, including same material as for Alternative 2, plus 10,000 square feet of LBP-containing wall material and 3,000 sq. feet of non-friable ACM flooring. 

No Institutional controls necessary.

Most costly of the three alternatives.

Removal estimated at $137,730.  Cost does not include replacement of removed items

Home ] Up ] Search ] Contacts ] Mayor ] City Officials ] Council Members ] Agenda/Meetings ] Meeting Schedule ] Park & Recreation ] Historic Shelby ] Newsletter ] Shelby Business ] Community Profile ] Animal Control ] Animal Ordinance ] Shelby Churches ] ACH Form ]

Links

Senator Max Baucus
www.baucus.senate.gov

Senator John Tester
www.tester.senate.gov/

Dennis Rehberg
www.house.gov/writerep/

ChampionsPark

Port Authority

Shelby Schools

KSEN

Toole County

Marias Museum

Shelby Area Job

Corrections Corp.

Marias Medical Center

Marias Valley Golf & C.C.

Community Calendar Chamber of Commerce

 Shelby Promoter

1923 World Heavyweight Championship Fight

COMMUNITY VIDEO


Need Real Player for Video
 

Questions or problems regarding this web site should be directed to [Stirling Web Design].
Copyright © 2002 [City of Shelby]. All rights reserved.
Last modified: 05/07/08.